[Reader-list] democracy at work

[Vivek Narayanan]

Dear Friends,

I just received this e-mail from my dear friend Oksana Zabuzhko, one of
Ukraine's leading intellectuals whom many of you met when she was a Fullbright
fellow here more than ten years ago.  A poet, philosopher, translator of Sylvia
Plath (as well as of Lucie Brock-Broido, Sue Standing, and Marie Howe),
vice-chair of Ukraine's PEN club, and a contributing editor to Agni 
for nearly fifteen
years, Oksana describes a terrifying turn of events in Ukraine, including a
violent public assault by organized thugs on a peaceful gathering in Kyiv a
couple of nights ago.

The immediate aim of the assaults is to create a climate of fear in the
country and to prevent free elections from taking place in Ukraine as scheduled
next Sunday (October 31).  The violence is closely linked to Putin's efforts to
bring Ukraine into Russia's sphere of influence--by force, if necessary.

The Western media has not been following or publicizing events surrounding
the elections at all in the last months.  I have heard many explanations for
this.  When I was in Ukraine last August there was already a climate of high
anxiety that far exceeded even the fears surrounding our own elections.

The primary reason for this, in a nutshell, is that Prime Minister
Yanukhovych, poised to steal the elections with Putin's help, already 
has a criminal
recorded and has widely documented ties with criminal organizations.  In
addition, he is prepared to roll back many independence reforms in 
order to realign
Ukraine more closelty to Russia.

The consequences for ordinary people and intellectuals are likely to be
extreme.

The kind of intervention I believe in involves shining the light of reason on
violent actions.  In our time this light takes the form of a free press which
will not allow criminal behavior to go unaccounted for, neither in this
country nor abroad.

Just as our own press is finally waking up to the importance of publicizing
through images the consequences of our violence abroad, so should it be
prepared to forestall violence by making sure governments know their 
actions are
being scrutinized and observed and that they will be held accountable for them.

This situation seems to be on the edge of emergency.  All your efforts to
bring the world's attention to this matter will contribute to the 
growth of peace
and justice.  If the world turns its back on Ukraine now, we risk creating
another unstable region at a time when the global situation is already
precarious.  Without sounding alarmist, the nineteen thirties are 
around the corner.
We move toward them blindly at our own risk.

Sincerely,

Askold Melnyczuk
Founding Editor
AGNI





Kiev, October 24 2004

Dear friends,

I'm writing you this from the country, now haunted with the gory prospect of
being forcefully turned, in a week, into one of the most terrible
thugocratic dictatorships that Europe has witnessed since Hitler and Stalin.
You may find this an exaggeration, yet it's not. It's usually so human, to
refuse to believe the worst - until it's too late. Besides, from my recent
conversations with my friends and journalists from EU, I know how little
information can be found in the European media on the situation in Ukraine -
and, as a result, how little understanding there is of what is really at
stake here this fall.

Last night the first blood was spilled on the Kiev pavement. The autocratic
post-Soviet regime, which since the late 1990s has been smothering the
budding Ukrainian democracy, and is by now wholeheartedly hated by the
vast majority of population (from 67% to 85%, according to the polls!), has
given us its final proof, that there'll be NO - however heavily falsified -
"free elections" on October 31. There'll be a WAR - an open war, launched
against the people of Ukraine by the handful of gangsters now at power,
whose only goal is to stay at power after the 31st - at ANY price.

Until last night they've been using the "cold-war" methods (to skip the case
of an attempted poisoning of the oppositional candidate, Victor Yushchenko,
whose chances to win the elections in an honest game are undeniable).
There's been a disgusting and overwhelming campaign of lies in the media
(most of them, with very few exceptions, controlled by the power), there've
been all the dirty, illegal tricks used (payments, threats, repressions
etc.), as well as cheating with the voting lists (with, say, tens of
thousands of the dead included on them, etc). Nothing of these, though,
proved efficient enough to guarantee next Sunday the smooth and peaceful
victory to the "candidate of the power" - the present-day Prime Minister
(appointed by the president), a  former (?) criminal, back in his youth
twice convicted for robbery (no kidding!).

Yesterday, the grand "orange" manifestation (orange being the colour of the
oppositional candidate) of some 150000-200000 people filled the square in
front of the Central Election Committee, under the slogan "For honest and
transparent elections". It's been a warm, tranquil sunny day (do you know
how beautiful is Kiev in the fall?), and the 3-million city was all
celebration - of joy, and hope, and solidarity. It's been a long time since
I've seen so many happy, smiling faces in the streets - in fact, since the
collapse of the Soviet Union. Yet then, in 1991, as the past 13 years have
proved, our celebration was definitely premature. With no change of the
political elite, with just very small burgeons of civil society, with -
well, why don't I put it plainly - no REAL revolution, Ukraine, after a
while, started sliding back into the dark shadow of Sovietization. It's only
now, that the dragon of Soviet totalitarianism - in the meantime
considerably shrunken, losing one part of his body after another (Eastern
Europe - the Baltics - then, last fall, Georgia...), all rotten up to the
marrow of his bones (its true - criminal - skeleton now fully exposed!) - is
REALLY agonizing. And the convulsions of the dragon could be terrible -
isn't the case of Russia conspicuous enough?

Vladimir Putin, who's so shortly turned his country back into a
concentration camp, fully browbeaten with the fear of terrorism, now serves
as the major support for the Ukrainian thugs. Small wonder, as criminals and
the KGB officers used to belong together since good old Gulag times. The
whole presidential campaign of our "candidate of the power", Victor
Yanukovich, is a brainchild of Moscow professionals. Politically and
intellectually, Kiev now more and more looks like the city under Russian
occupation.And what exactly have they plotted to ensure "the succession of
power" in Ukraine, has become visible last night.

About 23:00, after the singing "orange" crowd in front of the Central
Election Committee dispersed, and only some 150 people - among them women,
and senior citizens - stayed to wait for the results of the session (which
was hold inside) to be announced (on the agenda was an attempt to falsify
some 2 million voices, due to the machinations with the voting lists!) - the
dragon has bared his teeth for the first time. Some 50 black-leathered men
appeared out of the darkness, and attacked people, who were waiting on the
park benches, with clubs and knives. There was no police around (!), but
three of the attackers - when the parlamentarians and the bodyguards ran out
of the building - were caught and handicuffed. According to their IDs, they
all appeared to be disguised policemen - of the specially trained "killers'
detachments".

Yes, there've been rumours circulating before - of some "special
detachments" arriving from all over the country and concentrating around the
city. Of some strange, and highly suspicious manoeuvres noted by the
city-dwellers in some areas. Now, next morning after the "night of the long
knives" (as a result of which, 11 peaceful demonstrators were taken to the
hospital, some of them seriously wounded), there's no doubt left: the war
has been announced. The gangsters at power aren't going to leave in any
case. They are going to fight - most probably, after the voting-booths will
be closed.

Could any, however "specially trained", groups of murderers REALLY work
against hundreds of thousands of people? (For people ARE going to go into
the streets on the election night, and Ukrainian internet is now boiling
with the discussions on how and where to meet, how to protect oneself
against the attacks, etc.). Well, maybe they couldn't. And Ukrainian army
will hardly agree to turn its guns against its own people, either. But on
October 28 - three days before the elections - there'll be a military
parade (!) in Kiev (nothing like this was ever held before on this date!).
And Russian president Vladimir Putin is coming to Kiev - allegedly, to take
part in the parade (?). And to stay in Kiev for 5 (?) days more. Again,
there're rumours - oh, these rumours! - that he'll be bodyguarded by some
bayonets. More precisely - with two divisions being particularly famous of
their operations in the Caucasus...

Maybe Ukraine has only one week left. One last week of the electrifying
autumn of free political discussions in the cafes and clubs, of gatherings,
manifestations, and - well, of hope. For, despite everything, there's an
extremely strong, and growing hope, I even daresay, an upsurging belief,
that the Ukrainian part of the dragon will be killed next Sunday with the
free will of the people. Today the anchorman on the last Ukrainian free TV
channel yet unclosed (Channel 5) was smiling the same way people were
yesterday in the streets. (For quite a while persecuted, now sued, Channel 5
is under the threat of being closed tomorrow night - but the anchorman was
smiling like a winner.) Now covering no more than 30% of the country's
territory, Channel 5 was the only one which gave a full report on the events
of the last night. Characteristically, none of the beaten witnesses sounded
"victimized" - they all talked indignantly, but righteously: that is, like
people aware of their rights, and ready to protect them.

It's a totally irrational, yet overwhelming feeling: that "we", the people,
are stronger than "them", the corrupted power. And that it's "them", not
"us", who is scared.

On the night of the elections I'll be in the streets, too. I don't know what
is going to happen there. That is, what forces will be turned against us,
and what will be the final result. Yet, even if the worst happens, and the
Putin's bayonets help to turn my country, for God-knows-how-long, into a
criminal-presided reservation of the degraded Stalinist type, we'll be in
the streets - if only to be able to say, that THIS IS NOT OUR CHOICE.

Knowing how easily (and, more than once, eagerly!) does Western press buy
the "made-in-Russia" political myths on the current Ukrainian situation (on
Ukraine being allegedly "split" into East and West, "pro-Russian" and
"pro-Western", Russian-speaking and Ukrainian-speaking parts, each of them
allegedly delegating its own candidate for the presidency), I just wanted to
let you know how the things look and feel here in the reality. By spreading
the truth further, you'll make your own contribution into killing the
dragon. For, as we all know from this old guy Orwell (WHO on earth has ever
been so careless to have claimed him outdated?) - what the dragon needs most
badly for its survival, is precisely the fake, artificially constructed
mental picture. And - needless to say that - the agony of the dragon should
by no means be lightheartedly taken as a local process only...

It's not a farewell letter - it's a letter of hope.

Please keep your fingers for us this week!

With warmest regards,

Oksana Zabuzhko

http://www.zabuzhko.com


-- 

AGNI Magazine
Sven Birkerts, Editor
William Pierce, Senior Editor

Check out our website, featuring online-only work:  http://agni.bu.edu

"Poetry is very different from philosophical thinking. And yet it 
cannot base or build its difference on ignoring it. I think the 
difference should be conscious; poetry should have a conscious 
relationship to the field of thinking, which is the field of 
contradictions. Starting from there, poetry has something, some 
supplement-what the French call the supplement d'ame, the supplement 
of the soul."
-- from "Between Athens & Jerusalem: A Conversation with Adam 
Zagajewski" by Brian Barker and Todd Samuelson, in AGNI Online

To subscribe to an AGNI email list, or unsubscribe, go to:
http://www.bu.edu/agni/agnimail/index.html