[Reader-list] Re: Bargirls-trafficking

[Rakesh]

This is a multi-part message in MIME format.

--MIMEStream=_0+100389_7248737917816_8871191616
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit


            Monday, July 04, 2005

      Close this window
            Columns


      Barred minds and bar girls

      Rakesh Shukla

      In a temporary reprieve, the ordinance banning dance bars in
Maharashtra has been returned by the governor. However, with an all-party
consensus including socialist-feminist Mrinal Gore, the ban is bound to
translate into law in the forthcoming assembly session.

      The media is replete with reports that the crackdown on dance bars in
Maharashtra has led to minor girls being trafficked into Delhi. By all
accounts, the bar 'girls' in Maharashtra are in fact adult women. In fact,
last year the Bhartiya Bargirls Union, the first-ever trade union of
bargirls, was formed. In August, they held a demonstration culminating in
Mumbai's Azad Maidan demanding better working conditions and had posters
like "Bar bala bhi veer bala hai" (the bar girl is also a brave girl). They
do not appear to have been "trafficked" through coercion into the
profession. Nor do they look too keen to be "rehabilitated" into lowly-paid
sewing work. Like it or not, bar girls clearly want to continue in the
profession.


      Women in prostitution have also found strength in numbers, the most
well-known union being the Durbar Mahila Samanvay Committee in Kolkata with
about 60,000 members. In Maharashtra there is VAMP, the Veshya Aids Mukabla
Parishad. These groups work towards less exploitative working conditions and
effective access to health services. In a country, where many wives cannot
ensure condom use by their husbands, it is a remarkable that many of these
groups have successfully enforced mandatory condom use by client-customers.


      The vital issue of ensuring less exploitative conditions for bar girls
and sex workers gets bogged down due to their alleged links with
trafficking. In the public consciousness, sex workers and bar girls get
equated to trafficking. Yet a recent study on bar girls by Mumbai's SNDT
University and the Forum against Oppression of Women did not "see any case
of trafficking as is being talked about in the media and by the proponents
of the ban".


      The law relating to prostitution/sex work - the earlier Suppression of
Immoral Traffic Act (SITA), which has now been rechristened the Immoral
Traffic Prevention Act - both make the same mistake. The legislation deals
with acts like keeping a brothel/soliciting in a public place. It neither
has a definition of trafficking nor any provision pertaining to it. Yet so
deeply is the association of prostitution with trafficking, that the law
with regard to prostitution is called Prevention of "immoral traffic".


      However, the provision merely reflects the second association which
blocks any discussion about steps to improve the work environment of
categories like that of bar girls and sex workers. In every meeting that sex
workers have had with other sections in society, the discussion gets stuck
on the issue of "consent". Sex workers keep trying to take the discussion
forward. However, other participants steadfastly refuse to move beyond, "Are
sex workers not forced into prostitution?" The questions are posited as if
everyone else in any other job or profession has exercised a wonderful free
choice. Persons come into sex work through a variety of ways and for
differing reasons, just like they do in other professions. Yes, some are
forced into it and may wish to continue while others may want to leave.
Caste, class, other factors are ignored and the discussion revolves around
"consent".


      Trafficking is abominable. However, trafficking means the use of
threats, force, coercion, fraud or deception on the person involved. No
organisation working towards the de-criminalisation of sex work or the
rights of bar girls to continue their profession, is in favour of
trafficking. Similarly, no organisation is advocating entry of minors into
these professions. There is a consensus that there should be no minors in
the industry. The difference, perhaps, lies in the way to go about
prevention. The age-old methods of raid and rescue have not worked in
preventing the entry of minors. The alternative strategy of working through
gharwalis or 'madams' is being tried out by some organisations with moderate
success. There are still minors in the profession but the numbers appear to
be significantly lower. The strategy needs to be given a fair chance.
Madams, of course, are exploitative. Some treat their 'girls' badly, pay
less and provide no protection against cruel clients.


      All the more reason to move away from the association of sex work and
bar girls with trafficking.




      The writer is a Supreme Court advocate



      URL: http://www.indianexpress.com/full_story.php?content_id=73793




--------------------------------------------------------------------------

      Expressindia | The Indian Express | The Financial Express | Screen
      Kashmir Live | Loksatta | Lokprabha

      About Us | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Labelled
with ICRA
      © 2005: Indian Express Newspapers (Bombay) Ltd. All rights reserved
throughout the world.


--MIMEStream=_0+100389_7248737917816_8871191616
Content-Type: image/gif; name="ie_logo_ins.gif"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--MIMEStream=_0+100389_7248737917816_8871191616
Content-Type: image/gif; name="printstory.gif"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64

R0lGODlhgwASAJEAAP///wAAAJmZmY2NjCH5BAAAAAAALAAAAACDABIAAALyhB2peu0Po5y02otb
gEr4D4biSJbmiabqeWzPksXyTNeN0ALDvgOuDQwKbTgEZ4hMKiNFn443cEpgCEbVlcgtrFfYT2ql
vhjb7FUTdvxwXPRXk5PKf2a5/QWPg/P8uVpPZyRoIIBVZvY2iAWoNXj3p+f3CIkXuad4V2iRKBmI
uWhJ6bMFyNmS+PUGapeoWcEpJtbJOpHKp2pa1afaJUqYu9EWujprO7UbOnnbd8nr4EoBWyk5Zxxh
PTu8vE39WAgFDiUtGox4ykyeFyZ8WvfYZt16OL9Ub0/UdK+/H+TB/w9Qhr+ABAsyWYEwocKFDBuG
KAAAOw==

--MIMEStream=_0+100389_7248737917816_8871191616--