[Reader-list] A Modest Appeal to Election Propagandists

[bipin]

Dear All,

Who says Muslims are harassed from 1000 years. On the contrary they have ruled over India and Hindu remain poor and slave during Muslim and British rule. Now Muslims are poor for their own reason and don't want to come out of their fence, don't want to amalgamate with Indian like Parsi did and don't want to develop themselves. They are having much more children and could not able to take care of them upto the standard and remain poor. Due to more children, they are unable to give proper education, personalize care and remain backward in humanity also. Those who comes out of their fence are definitely came up and living their healthy life. You will find many such Muslims not only in city even in the villages. For all these if you can make survey, I am sure you will find that they are having small family of maximum 2 or 3 children and one wife. There leader or mullah wants that they remain backward for their own selfish reason to remain in power. However, the things are getting change now and Muslims or even other poor people coming out of their leaders' trap and lauding their own voice. This is good sign and you will see the change in about one decade positively. 

 

Your point for Muslims like sentencing to death, raping of woman, deprived of right to vote are foolish. Death sentence was given by court after passing several processes. Such punishment not imposed overnight and it is not only for Muslim but all the community. Raping of woman is applicable to all community, why separating Muslims for this. By this sentence don't misunderstood that I am favoring rape. It was misunderstood earlier. Who deprived them from voting? Since independence they are voting on mass basis even more than other community. Might be some illegal migrant will be there in your mind for depriving from voting!!! Actually the people like you by such foolish argument separating Muslim community from whole India. If Muslims are ready to apply Uniform Civil Code will be benefited to them only for their upliftment. Don't say that I am speaking BJP language, this is my personal view since long even before BJP.

 

Development of Nation means inclusive growth for all and that is only possible if you make root based development. Since years, we have tried subsidy based development, but what was outcome of it? Nothing. As I say real infrastructural development started before few years and if it will continue, you can see the result. I never said what happened in the past (Nehru, Indira, Rajiv, Advani, Modi and others, list will be much larger) are right. But, today who ever make real development must be appreciated and put forward. Whoever, it may be. Now, time has come to govern the country by efficient, dynamic and knowledgeable persons irrespective of him/her being a politician or non-politician. There is no question of praising Atalji because he is in BJP, but he did some real developmental work during his tenure. I am sure if Manmohansingh would have free hand without coalition compulsion would have done much better work.

 

When the development takes place, it is for everyone and does not have any label for only Hindu and not for Muslim. Root based development reaches to all for which I am insisting always, while schemes kept in mind for particular section have their limitations. Also, in our corrupted country it will have very remote benefits.

 

For any of the above point if I am wrong, I invite all the members to point me out.



thanks

Bipin


----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Rakesh Iyer 
  To: bipin 
  Cc: Aditya Raj Kaul ; sarai-list 
  Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2009 4:02 PM
  Subject: Re: [Reader-list] A Modest Appeal to Election Propagandists


  Dear all

  I think simply advertising is not what this site is meant for. And as for Aditya, Pawan, Bipin and others, everybody here, I would like to ask something:

  You all have been cribbing that Muslims did this and that in the last 1,000 years ago. And they continue to do some other things as well, all of which are wrong. You also say that secularists are trying to save these Muslims and disturbing Hindus as well. What do you want: Muslims to be punished for their alleged atrocities for the past 1,000 years (by killing them, sentencing to death, raping their women or something else), or be subjected to economic hardships for this, or be deprived of right to vote, or something else? Do you wish that secularists should be also sentenced to any of these? Or both of them? 

  What is your conception of the nation? What is meant in your terms by development of the nation? 

  You put up articles supporting the right-wing stand. You always argue indirectly or directly that the BJP is in some way right, or the issues they raised at least are right. You even point out that Kashmiri Muslims have done this or that, Godhra has happened etc. What is your conception of Indian Muslims? 

  And what are you against? Indian Muslims? Secularism? Congress? Left? Something else? And what are you for? Sangh Parivar? BJP? or Right Wing ideology? So-called Genuine secularism? Something else?

  Instead of advertising Vajpayee and supporting him, better speak about your own views to begin with. As for Vajpayee, we all know how he was sacked by the Indian public from power and what was the result of his India Shining campaign.

  And yes, for all my answers to questions I have raised I would write another mail, but only after some time. Please do bear with me for that. 

  Regards

  Rakesh