[Reader-list] The Communist Conspiracy !

[Pawan Durani]

Dear Mr Ray,

Few of my questions remain unanswered and few more have developed

Are the Communists on payroll of Russia or China ?

Do they work on the instructions from these two super powers ?

Since you have expressed helpless of an alleged terrorist "Madani"
supporting the left in Kerela , would you have a similar arrangement with
Sri Ram Sene in future in Kerela ?

If not what holds the left back ?

Why would we accept that left is sincere ? They dont stick to an ideology .

Why did Communist Party split happen in the first place ?

Are the communist still ambitious about dividing India into smaller
sovereign states ?

Pawan





On Sun, Apr 19, 2009 at 2:38 PM, prakash ray <pkray11 at gmail.com> wrote:

> Dear Rakesh Ji,
>
> Let me first congrutulate you for your cent percent political
> correctedness.
> I thank you also for the questions you have asked. I try to reply them.
>
> 1) The V.P.Singh govt was formed after the congress govt led by Mr Rajiv
> Gandhi was voted out. The popular mandate was to form a non-Congress
> government. As you know the movement against the Rajiv Gandhi govt was led
> by Mr V P Singh, a former congressman and senior cabinet minister in the
> previous govt. So, he was the only choice for the top job. The Left Front
> ensured that BJP should not be part of the govt. The Front also ensured
> that
> the govt initiate pro-people policies. If you have even little awareness,
> the recomendations of the B P Mandal Commission for reservations of OBCs in
> jobs was implemented by the V P Singh govt. You must know that ABVP and
> NSUI
> supporters violently protested this across the country. The student who was
> the first to try to self-immolate was visited by Mr Advani in AIIMS and was
> elected as the president of DUSU unopposed as an NSUI candidate. Mr
> Advani's
> bloody Rath-yatra was stopped in Bihar and he was arrested. soonafter, the
> BJP decided to withdraw support but the Left stood strongly with V P Singh.
> The Congress broke the Janata Dal and made Mr Chandrashekhar the PM.
> However, soon they withdraw support and it collapsed. The Left continue to
> ally with the secularists like Laloo and Mulayam to contain the communal
> politics of the RSS-BJP. You must know that period was the most dangerous
> period for the secular India. Moreover, during this period, an ultra-Left
> student organisation AISA was formed as the student wing of
> CPI-ML-Liberation which raised slogans of 'No Mandal, No Kamandal, Inqalab
> Zindabad' and swept the students union polls in many campuse in the
> northern
> part of the country. For its political bankruptcy and opportunism, it soon
> lost its glory and the ABVP replaced it in these campuses.
>
> I hope you understand the context of the support to the VP Singh govt. The
> importance of that govt lies in the fact that it broke the tradition of
> Congress's political hegemony and new political formations/parties earned
> importance. If you still want to call it a political opportunism,  I have
> nothing more to say on this.
>
> The way you have ridiculed the Mandal Report and blamed the Left for the
> rise of the Kamandal politics, you need to introspect. Was it wrong to
> implement the Report? Would it have been correct to let the Congress rule
> the country? What should you have done if you were a member of Lok Sabha at
> that time?
>
> 2) The Left is working towards the formation of a non-Congress and non-BJP
> front. The Left had supported the UPA govt led by the Congress respecting
> the mandate for a secular govt. But, the Congress betrayed the commitment
> articulated in the CMP. Despite having differences and apprehensions, the
> Left is trying to build an alliance on the broader agenda of secularism,
> democracy, pro-people policies, anti-imperialism. You must note the fact
> that many parties are joining hands with the Left leaving the NDA and the
> UPA. Moreover, the Congress, Laloo and Mulayam are praising the Left for
> its
> positive role. Also, CPI-ML-Liberation has joined forces this time with the
> Left in Bihar. Mind you, in politics or in life, one has to make alliances.
> Life cannot be run only by irresponsible cynicism or anarchism.
>
> 3) The BJD realised its blunders and left the BJP. Let me tell you little
> more that the Left and the BJD have joined hands with the NCP in Orissa to
> defeate the Congress and the BJP. You should not be surprised if you learn
> that JD-U also joins the Left soon after the general elections.
>
> 4) As far as the Bengal govt is concerned, there is a great need to
> generate
> jobs. This is also true for the entire country. I share the concern
> regarding the mode of development adopted by various parties including the
> Left. The Left cannot and must not implement policies/programmes which can
> go against the people. The events in Nandigram and Singur were disturbing
> and the Left govt must learn a lesson. However, the situation was made
> worse
> by the TMC-Maoists combine aided by the Congress and the BJP. The need of
> the hour is to formulate a comprehensive developmental policy keeping all
> aspects in consideration. b
>
> 5) The Left does not have any alliance with Madani in Kerala. However, even
> in you opinion, he is 'allegedly' a terrorist. If a group extend supports
> to
> the Left, what it can do. As far as the central agencies are concerned,
> they
> are themselves communal in character and also they have only registered
> failures as far as terrorism is concerned. The Big Boss of these agencies,
> Nation Security Advisor, takes more interest in deals and lobbying.
>
> Taslima Nasreen was never ousted. The govt merely advised her against
> staying in Kolkata at that time since some groups had objected. It was a
> momentary step. You must know that after that episode, Ms Nasreen has
> visited Kolkata several times.
>
> 6) Com Pinarayi Vijayan has never been accused of corruption nor indicted
> in
> any report. The enquiry is still on. Till it is over, stop yourself from
> acting as a judge.
>
> PKR
>  _________________________________________
> reader-list: an open discussion list on media and the city.
> Critiques & Collaborations
> To subscribe: send an email to reader-list-request at sarai.net with
> subscribe in the subject header.
> To unsubscribe: https://mail.sarai.net/mailman/listinfo/reader-list
> List archive: &lt;https://mail.sarai.net/pipermail/reader-list/>
>