[Reader-list] Ayodhya, 6 December 1992: An Account

[Rakesh Iyer]

Hope you all read the article, and give your own views, particularly as the
Liberhan Commission has submitted its report now afte 17 years, and the
culprits of this act and the repercussions after that still roam free.

Article from Tehelka:

*‘Advani Looked Disturbed... Mouth Gaping Open’*

*He saw each dome of the Babri Masjid fall one by one. Ayodhya’s sky was all
smoke and fire. A first-hand account*

*PRASHANT PANJIAR
* *Photographer*
 [image: image]

*Men of another god* Karsewaks demolish the domes of the Babri Masjid in
1992
*Photos:*PRASHANT PANJIAR/INDIA TODAY

ON DECEMBER 5, 1992, I was in Lucknow covering LK Advani’s rally. All BJP
leaders had been doing a yatra across UP, and *India Today *had asked me to
follow him. That night, after the speeches subsided, all the journalists
dispersed. Something told me to stay. I followed Advani after the rally and
landed up at Kalyan Singh’s house. I was the only photographer there. They
let me in. All the top BJP leaders — Atal Behari Vajpayee, Murli Manohar
Joshi — were present, meeting inside a room. I could sense the tension in
the air.

When Advani stepped out at midnight, I casually asked what time he’d leave
for Ayodhya the next day. “Right now,” he replied. Suddenly Vajpayee
emerged, headed for New Delhi. Something wasn’t as they had expected. I
called my reporter colleague and we rushed out too.

In Ayodhya, we traced Advani at Mahant Paramhans’ ashram meeting with Vinay
Katiyar from the Bajrang Dal, Ashok Singhal from the VHP and HV Seshadri
from the RSS. We learned that the karsewaks were completely determined to
bring down the mosque.

I followed Advani as he left the ashram. Along with other BJP and VHP
leaders, he arrived at the platform facing the disputed shrine to review
arrangements for symbolic pujas which were to commence at 11:30am. Chants of
*Jai Shri Ram* had begun. 200 meters away, a stage had been set up on an
open terrace in a building called the Ram Katha Kunj. Advani walked to the
dais. I followed. From the edge of the terrace, diagonally, I could only see
the domes of the Babri Masjid, but nothing beyond and below.

All the Sangh leaders — Uma Bharti, Sadhvi Ritambara, Vijay Raje Scindia, MM
Joshi, Seshadri, Advani, Pramod Mahajan — were on the stage. Somehow they
thought I was a VHP photographer so they let me stay. Most other
photographers were at the puja tents. Little did they know that RSS sewaks
had already been appointed to stop them from clicking the moment the
demolition began.

Back on the stage, Advani and Seshadri looked nervous. The pujas began; so
did the speeches. At around 11:30am people started climbing the domes.
Photographers started clicking. The karsewaks pounced on them. They were
pushed into a room and locked up. Those who resisted were beaten. “We’ll
break your legs if you try to come out,” they were told.

I was the only photographer who had a clear view of the domes. Through the
lens, I could see men with iron rods beating on a dome. There was laughter
on the stage. Suddenly, a larger group of people appeared on the top of the
dome, and it looked like the beginnings of a serious attack. At this point,
I turned towards the leaders. I could see the faces of Advani and Seshadri.
They looked disturbed. A little later, I would see them in front of the
stage wide-eyed, with their mouths gaping open. Around them, the other
leaders on stage looked pleased with themselves. It seemed that Advani was
trying to signal to the other VHP leaders – ‘Enough, now call them down.’
But the others weren’t satisfied and wanted ‘a little more’. This was when I
began to understand the urgency of the previous night in Lucknow. I think
the BJP leaders received information that the karsewaks weren’t going to
listen to them. Vajpayee rushed to Delhi to damage control. Advani rushed to
Ayodhya early and Kalyan Singh stayed in Lucknow. I think Advani had been
promised by the Ram Janambhoomi movement that they’d create a ruckus but
ensure the mosque is not demolished. But this doesn’t absolve Advani of
culpability.

Meanwhile, the others were laughing in great delight. When the first dome
began to crack, there were loud cheers from Uma Bharati, Sadhvi Ritambara
and Scindia. They egged on the karsewaks with chants of *“Ek Dhaka Aur Do,
Babri Masjid Tod Do”.*

By this time, I received information that most of the other photographers
had been beaten up. I realised that I was the only one who could photograph
the domes falling. I knew I had to be careful. By mid-day, the domes were
being attacked with full force. I saw people walking away from the Masjid
carrying long pillars on their head.

At one point, I overheard Advani ask Pramod Mahajan to go ‘check what was
going on’. Advani never left the stage, but all the other leaders were doing
trips back and forth. Mahajan came back, and I overheard again. “Nothing can
be done. They’ve tied ropes from behind. They will pull down the domes.”

It got hotter by mid-afternoon. I had been there the entire day without food
or water. I remember sitting on a chair at one point, my head falling in a
slump. A swami came up to me and asked, “Why is your head down? Are you not
happy (about the demolition)?” By 4:30pm, two of the domes were gone. I shot
the sequence. Initially there had been a lot of chaos but as the operation
progressed it seemed to be a systematic demolition, one dome after the
other.

Some of the photographers who had been beaten up had managed to escape and
come to the stage. I borrowed a longer lens from one of them. His camera had
been smashed and he was too shocked to shoot. With the longer lens, I shot
the last dome as it fell. I saw it tilt, and remain titled for a second
until it smashed on the ground. A cloud of dust rose to fill the empty air.
The sight of that last dome, titled in mid-air, about to fall, remains a
striking image. There was complete jubilation on the stage. Soon, I saw the
city’s horizon pierced with spirals of smoke. An acharaya said into the
mike, “Look at these Muslims, they are burning their own homes to malign
us.” The karsewaks went berserk. The killing began. The sky was all smoke
and fire.

A young woman police officer came to the Rama Katha Kunj aghast. She said
the entire town was out of control. She told me about two photographers –
Nitin Rai and Pablo Bartholomew, who the karsewaks were trying to lynch. She
saved them by saying she’s arresting them.
 ‘The Muslims are burning their homes to malign us,’ said an acharya, and
the karsewaks went berserk

When I came down from the stage, all I could see were logs of wood, road
blocks, fire, people brandishing sticks and rods. By 7:30pm most journalists
escaped from Ayodhya. I too managed to get into a car and head to Faizabad,
where we were staying.

I returned later next day to photograph the aftermath. The hillock where the
mosque stood was now covered with pink tents. The karsewaks had begun
constructing the makeshift temple.

Seventeen years after the demolition, it isn’t the falling of the domes that
has left a lasting impression. Rather, it was the acharya’s words as the
smoke spiraled from Muslim homes that remains the most defining moment. The
demolition of a mosque can be part of the politics of hatred, but what
stopped Advani from walking up to the same microphone? One appeal from him
to stop the killing would have saved many lives. The lack of that was the
most defining thing for me. It was the complete absence of courage.

 *From Tehelka Magazine, Vol 6, Issue 27, Dated July 11, 2009*