[Reader-list] CONGRESSULATIONS

[bipin]

Dear Anupam,

All the PM of India has elected as MP, while only Singh as PM elected from 
Rajya Sabha. This time also ha has not contested the election, but will be 
PM by Rajya Sabha member, that is back door.

Chidambaram/Pawar failed to counter heavy increase in the price of essential 
commodities. They did nothing to counter it, even after recession all the 
price has gone down, but essential commodities price were not going down, 
but on the contrary gone up. Who is responsible? Pawar is most corrupted 
politician ((if you ask proof, no body can prove this) holding powerful 
lobby of rich farmers and made heavy money this way. Free economy introduced 
by Manmohansingh from 1991 onwards and took steps of less govt. hindrance 
for industries was somehow reverted by Chidambaram by introducing black law 
like FBT. FBT was opposed by almost all the section, but he didn't listen to 
it. He introduced import license for many surgical items. Increased TDS 
rates heavily. Chidambaram was influenced by IT practissioner and 
consultant, CFA agent lobby. After knowing all this, Manmohansingh did 
nothing, so also he was counted as weak PM, who has no control on his 
ministers.

BJP way of opposition of shouting in the house and not allowed to run the 
house many times was created bad impression in the voter in this live 
telecast era. Of course there are many reasons of BJP defeat. One of the 
reason is immature Varun Gandhi behavior. BJP is very anthuny in projecting 
PMs. They did mistake to project advani as PM, before about 2 years of 
election and this time Narendra Modi as next (2014) as PM post. This created 
negative impact on the voter. Since outside Gujarat, yet Modi acceptability 
is not there. He has to still work on this part by doing more developmental 
and fruitful work (than what he did till date) in Gujarat and center stage. 
This was the key reason of BJP defeat what I believe.

Outside WB and Kerala, it is general perception in peoples mind that 
communists are anti development party. Other perception is that they believe 
poor people has right to fight for their poorness, farmers has right to 
fight for their land where they work, but actually belong to other rich 
farmers. So, the nexalite activities has begun. I don't remember exactly, 
but in some historical books, in the earlier years I read that communists 
encourage naxalwad may be in the earlier times and not now, but this is 
general perception for the communists. This is the reason they did not get 
room in other states. Many articles of today also sometime elaborate this 
truth.

thanks
Bipin

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "anupam chakravartty" <c.anupam at gmail.com>
To: "sarai list" <reader-list at sarai.net>
Sent: Sunday, May 17, 2009 1:11 PM
Subject: Re: [Reader-list] CONGRESSULATIONS


> dear bipin,
>
> can you substantiate the following claims. i will be really interested if
> you could:
>
> 1. Manmohanji, without electing as MP you made history to be PM again from
> back door. ( Don't you think its the constitution that gives such a
> provision which allow manmohan to become a legitimate PM?)
>
> 2. Also its golden chance for you to keep Chidambaram and Pawar out of
> finance and agricultural ministry as they were totally failure in this 
> front
> and allowed to increase prices of essential commodity for their selfish
> motto. It is little wonder also that voter, even poor voter has not
> considered this point while voting. (Chidambaram and Pawar can be kept out
> of ministry but how do you say that they would favour the increase in 
> prices
> of essential commodities? and then you go on to cite poor voter has not
> considered this point? isnt little absurd to make such a statement. anyway
> unless you have proof, i am not to dispute it)
>
> 3. i am also amazed by your use of the word "backdoor". As in how many 
> times
> the strategies planned by political parties are "frontdoor".
>
> 4. "Also people want BJP to do constructive opposition role, which was
> lacking many cases last time and this is one reason for you to voted out.
> This is punishment for you." (BJP has been punished not because of its 
> role
> as opposition. As an opposition, BJP scores more than any of the other
> parties including the left especially when it comes matters of national
> interest.)
>
> 5. Its real time to retrospect communists ... naxalites backing. (How do 
> you
> say that Communists as in the CPM and CPI (M) back naxalites?)
>
> with regards
> anupam
>
>
>
> On 5/17/09, bipin <aliens at dataone.in> wrote:
>>
>> Congratulations to Congress. Well done Manmohansingh, Sonia, Rahul.
>>
>> Manmohanji, without electing as MP you made history to be PM again from
>> back door. Perhaps voter like your generosity, honesty, simplicity (which 
>> is
>> lacking in most of the politician) leads to the victory path. Now you 
>> have
>> got golden chance to prove yourself as stronger PM which was shown by you 
>> in
>> only case of nuclear agreement. Also its golden chance for you to keep
>> Chidambaram and Pawar out of finance and agricultural ministry as they 
>> were
>> totally failure in this front and allowed to increase prices of essential
>> commodity for their selfish motto. It is little wonder also that voter, 
>> even
>> poor voter has not considered this point while voting. It is good fortune
>> and stars for congress. Good Luck.
>>
>> Congrats Soniaji and your team, backdoor strategists for this victory.
>> However, it is lollipop and even you have not expected such huge win this
>> time as well as in 2004 also. Both win proved very lucky for you and this
>> time you are free to work on real development work without hindrance and
>> pressure tactics from allies.
>>
>> Congrats Rahulji. Youth people has massly voted to your youth appeal. 
>> This
>> is the real reason for congress win. Since it was direct comparison with 
>> 80
>> year old Advani. Keep it up. Grab this golden opportunity with some real
>> developmental work to carry out instead of going to the vote bank 
>> politics.
>>
>> Consolation to Advani. You are very good person, good at heart but late 
>> in
>> your mission. Your age was the biggest hindrance and did not get mass 
>> appeal
>> against youth. BJP should rethink and encourage youth. Also people want 
>> BJP
>> to do constructive opposition role, which was lacking many cases last 
>> time
>> and this is one reason for you to voted out. This is punishment for you. 
>> So
>> perform the constructive opposition role and you will be benefited
>> definitely in the near future.
>>
>> Consolation to Communists. Its real time to retrospect communists
>> themselves and think on the direction of real development and come out of
>> their labor union politics, naxalites backing, US hatred (I am not saying 
>> US
>> is right all the way, but what is their good we must adopt it), 
>> unnecessary
>> minority appeasement.
>>
>> I salute voter, who shown great maturity by electing one of the national
>> party for steady and healthy progress. Voters has experienced two 
>> coalition
>> rule of NDA and UPA and noticed regional/left parties behavior and made 
>> up
>> their mind this time to limit the regional parties. Congratulation to 
>> voter
>> by diminishing regional party and stop them taking undue advantage by
>> pressure tactics from politics and by that way saved the huge money which
>> was wasted by horse trading.
>>
>> UP and Bihar voters shown real maturity this time and they cut down all
>> criminal MPs were there in last tenure. They did not got permission to
>> contest the election and all have came up with their wives to contest, 
>> but
>> they all were defeated this time. This is the real difference what we 
>> need
>> and I am sure UP and Bihar will be on the track of development in the 
>> very
>> near future.
>>
>> thanks
>> BIPIN
>>
>> N.B Could not trace congress mail address. If anyone can give please 
>> inform
>> me.
>> _________________________________________
>> reader-list: an open discussion list on media and the city.
>> Critiques & Collaborations
>> To subscribe: send an email to reader-list-request at sarai.net with
>> subscribe in the subject header.
>> To unsubscribe: https://mail.sarai.net/mailman/listinfo/reader-list
>> List archive: &lt;https://mail.sarai.net/pipermail/reader-list/>
> _________________________________________
> reader-list: an open discussion list on media and the city.
> Critiques & Collaborations
> To subscribe: send an email to reader-list-request at sarai.net with 
> subscribe in the subject header.
> To unsubscribe: https://mail.sarai.net/mailman/listinfo/reader-list
> List archive: &lt;https://mail.sarai.net/pipermail/reader-list/>