[Reader-list] Reg: Article on Salwa Judum

[Rakesh Iyer]

Hi

While I have been reading articles on Sarai off and on, I feel that the list
has become meandering, in the sense that it's just been restricted to
posting of articles. Sarai, I feel, was created to bring about a spirit of
discussion, and also acquiring sufficient knowledge in the process, to
understand each and every issue. And yes, for my part or share, I will
accept the blame in not having done so.

In this context, I am posting this article, with the hope that we can now
discuss on this issue and try and discuss the phenomenon of Naxalism, the
wrong ways of tackling it (Salwa Judum), and the possible ways of tackling
both Naxal-sponsored and state-sponsored terror.

Rakesh


Link: http://outlookindia.com/article.aspx?263777

Article:

Chhattisgarh
An Anthropologist In A Police State

Is there no limit to the state's paranoia? Why is it so scared of those who
do nothing more dangerous than teach and write that it feels they should be
denied lodging, detained, provided 'protection', intimidated, 'escorted' out
of the state?

 Nandini Sundar<http://outlookindia.com/peoplefnl.aspx?pid=4374&author=Nandini+Sundar>

Ujjwal Kumar Singh, Professor of Political Science at Delhi University and I
have just returned (January 1st) from a visit to the police state of
Chhattisgarh. Ujjwal had gone for research and I had gone for a combination
of research and verification purposes to assess the livelihood situation of
villagers for our case before the Supreme Court, both entirely legitimate
activities. Indeed, to restrain a petitioner or witness from ensuring
compliance of the Court’s orders amounts to contempt of court. In Dantewada,
we had checked into Hotel Madhuban on the 29th of December around 2 pm
without any problems, only to be told later that night that the management
required the entire hotel to be instantly emptied out because they were
doing some puja to mark the death anniversary of the hotel owner. We refused
to leave at night, and were told we would have to leave at 6 am instead
because the rooms had to be cleaned. As expected, other guests checked in
the next morning, puja notwithstanding.

At Sukma, we were detained by the police and SPOs at the entrance to the
town from about 7.30 till 10 pm, with no explanation for why they had
stopped us, and no questions as to why we were there or what our plans were.
We were denied lodging – all the hotel owners had been told to claim they
were full and refuse us rooms, and the forest and PWD departments had been
advised not to make their guesthouses available, since ‘Naxalites’ were
coming to stay. Indeed, the police told us that these days Naxalites had
become so confident that they roamed around in jeeps on the highways. Since
everything was mysteriously full in a small town like Sukma, the police
advised us to leave that very night for Jagdalpur, some 100 km away. We
decided instead to spend the night in the jeep, since we did not want to
jeopardize friends by staying in their homes. Later, we contacted friends
and they arranged for us to stay in the college boys' hostel, since students
were away on vacation.

At midnight on the 30th, 6-7 armed SPOs burst into our room at the college
hostel, guns cocked, and then spent the night patrolling the grounds.
Evidently, the SPOs have seen many films and know precisely how to achieve
dramatic effect. They were also trying to open our jeep, presumably to plant
something. The next morning we were followed by seven armed SPOs with AK 47s
from Sukma in an unmarked white car, and this was replaced at Tongpal by 12
SPOs, in two jeeps. None of them had any name plates. Given that we could
have had no normal conversation with anyone, we decided to do all the things
one normally postpones.  In 20 years of visiting Bastar, for example, I have
never seen the Kutumbsar caves. Everywhere we went, including the haat at
Tongpal, the Tirathgarh waterfall  and the Kutumbsar caves, as well as shops
in Jagdalpur, the SPOs followed us, one pace behind, with their guns poised
at the ready. Two women SPOs had been deputed specially for me. The SPOs
also intimidated our jeep drivers by taking photos of them and the vehicle.

DGP Vishwaranjan claimed on the phone that it was for our ‘protection’ that
we were given this treatment since there was news of Naxalite troop
movement, and has gone on to say (*Indian Express*, 3rd Jan), “anything can
happen. Maoists can attack the activists to put the blame on the police. We
will deploy a few companies of security forces for the security of the
activists.”

Clearly all the other tourists in Tirathgarh and Kutumbsar were under no
threat from the Maoists – only we, who have been repeatedly accused of being
Naxalite supporters, were likely targets. As for the police ensuring that we
got no accommodation and trying to send us from Sukma to Jagdalpur in the
middle of the night, such pure concern for our welfare is touching.  The SP
of Dantewada, Amaresh Misra, was somewhat more honest when he said he had
instructions from above to ‘escort’ out ‘visiting dignitaries’. The
Additional SP shouted at us to be more ‘constructive’ – not surprisingly,
though, with 12 swaggering SPOs snapping at one’s heels, one is not always
at one’s constructive best. The next time, I promise to try.

The SPOs in their jeeps followed us some way from Jagdalpur to Raipur, even
when we were on the bus. In addition, two armed constables and an SI were
sent on the bus to ensure we got to Raipur. We overheard the SI telling the
armed constables to “take them down at Dhamtari” but fortunately this plan
was abandoned. This sounded so preposterous that we naively believed he
could not be referring to us, and looked around the bus for the ‘real’
Naxalites they meant to ‘take out’, casting suspicious eyes in particular on
a hapless passenger on the seat next to us, who spoke with what seemed to us
was a Telugu accent. (In the local version of profiling, vehicles with AP
numberplates and Telegu speakers have had a particular problem with the
police in CG since 2005 when Salwa Judum started). Such is the atmosphere of
terror that a police state creates, that even those who know better become
complicit with its demonic fears. The poor SI narrowly missed getting a
medal for bravery. As the good DGP tells the readers of the *Indian Express*,
it would have been passed off as an attack by Naxalites. On reaching Raipur,
the SI was confused. Shouting loudly and forgetting himself, as bad cell
connections are wont to make us all do, he said “The IG and SP had told me
to follow them, but now what do I do with them.”? The voice on the other end
told him to go home. We flew out of Raipur the next morning. In real terms,
this was a rather pointless exercise for the Chhattisgarh govt, since we
were scheduled to come home the following day anyway, bound by the
inexorable timetable of the university and classes. But symbolically, it
allowed the SPOs to gloat that they had driven us out.

The Chhattisgarh government obviously wants to ensure that no news on their
offensive or even on the everyday trauma of villagers reaches outside. Many
villages have been depopulated in the south, both due to the immense fear
created by Op. Green Hunt and the failure of the monsoons this year. All the
young people are migrating to AP for coolie work, leaving only children and
old people in the villages. There are sporadic encounters – the day we were
in Dantewada (29.12.09), two ‘Naxalites’ were killed in the jungles of
Vechapal and three arrested. A week before seven people had been killed in
Gumiapal. Who is getting killed and how is anyone’s guess. The Maoists are
blockading roads with trees and trenches, and killing ‘informers’. There is
compete terror, fear and hunger throughout the district.

While the Chhattisgarh govt was busy providing us ‘protection’, it has
refused to restore the armed guard that was taken away from CPI leader
Manish Kunjam. He has had credible reports that his life is under threat,
and he may face a replay of the Niyogi murder, because of his opposition
both to forcible and fraudulent land acquisition by multinationals like Tata
and Essar and to the Salwa Judum and Operation Green Hunt. Manish Kunjam,
whom I have known since the early 1990s, is the single most important mass
leader in the area who has been independent of both the state and Maoists,
and taken a stand on various issues. He is also a petitioner in the court
against Salwa Judum. Despite Raman Singh assuring the CPI leadership that
this would be done, the DGP has refused to act.

It is also remarkable that a government which can waste so many armed SPOs
for an entire day and night on two people who do nothing more dangerous than
teach and write, has been unable to catch the SPOs who are responsible for
raping six young women. Despite the trial court finding the SPOs and Salwa
Judum leaders prima facie guilty of rape and issuing a standing arrest
warrant on 30.10.2009, even two months later, they are ‘absconding’. Some of
them actively and openly participate in dharnas to block visiting activists,
but they are invisible to the police. Earlier in June 2009, the SP told the
Supreme Court that he could not find one of the victims, even though the day
before she had deposed in the trial court, and that therefore he had asked
the accused for an explanation. They had assured him there was no basis to
the charge and the women were only doing it to malign them in their brave
fight against Naxalism. In December, when local activist Himanshu Kumar, who
was instrumental in helping them to come to court, reported that the rape
victims were kept for 3-4 days in Dornapal thana and generally terrorized,
the Chief Secretary’s response was to accuse him of running an ‘ugly
motivated campaign.’ All good men these, good fathers, good husbands, good
citizens. So was DGP Rathore and all the honourable men who defended him,
promoted him and awarded him despite what he did to Ruchika. Unfortunately
for these adivasi girls, they are not middle class, so no media campaign for
them.

Bastar can no more get rid of me than I can get rid of Bastar. In 1992,
because I attended meetings to observe the protests by the villagers of
Maolibhata against the steel plant that was proposed to be sited there, the
government denied me access to the local archives. But it was the government
which then fell, and my book on Bastar, *Subalterns and Sovereigns*, was
published by 1997. In 2004, four of us were stopped in a village while doing
a survey of the Lok Sabha polls by village level sympathizers of the
Maoists. They retained Ajay TG’s video camera. The brilliant Chhattisgarh
police later arrested Ajay because the Maoists apologized and wanted to
return the camera. In 2005, Salwa Judum activists stopped us as part of the
PUDR-PUCL factfinding on Salwa Judum; in 2006, as part of the Independent
Citizens Initiative <http://www.outlookindia.com/article.aspx?231861>,
Ramachandra Guha, Farah Naqvi and I were stopped and searched in Bhairamgarh
thana by out-of-control SPOs, and Ramachandra Guha was nearly lynched inside
the station, while the thanedar was too drunk to read the letter we carried
from the Chief Secretary. My camera was taken away by a Salwa Judum leader,
and returned only months later. In 2007-8, the then SP, Rahul Sharma,
fabricated photos of me with my arms around armed Maoist women and showed
them to visiting journalists and others to try and discredit my
independence. He later claimed, when challenged, that the photos were of one
“Ms. Jeet’ and it was he who had verified the truth. In 2009, Ajay Dandekar
(historian), JP Rao (anthropologist) and I narrowly escaped a mob of around
300 Salwa Judum leaders, police and SPOs, who, however, took away JP Rao’s
mobile phones, a camera charger and vehicle registration documents from the
parked jeep. The police refused to register our complaint and detained us
for questioning for a few hours, even though we had got the consent of the
District Collector and the Mirtur CRPF contingent to visit Vechhapal. In
January 2010, a team of 15 activists from the National Alliance of People’s
Movements and other organizations were pelted with stones, eggs and cowdung
in Dantewada. The Salwa Judum lives and flourishes, under the new name of
the Ma Danteswari Samanvay Samiti, and the more organized label of ‘SPOs’,
encouraged by the cover of impunity granted by the centre and its
operations.

For anthropologists, our professional life is often difficult to separate
from our personal – our research depends on developing deep friendships with
the people we ‘study’. In the twenty years that I have been visiting Bastar
off and on, I have acquired a range of acquaintances, friends and people who
are like family members, whose concerns are my concerns. This does not in
any way diminish one’s commitment to independence and objectivity. The
relationship between anthropology and advocacy has long been a subject of
debate within the discipline, and within India, people like NK Bose, S.C.
Roy, AR Desai and many others have raised the question of the
anthropologist/sociologist’s social commitment. I have myself come down on
both sides of the divide, recognising that good research requires the kind
of whole time dedication that advocacy takes away from. On the other hand,
it is the generosity of people who are suffering, in sharing their time and
pain with us, that enables us to raise new and relevant questions for
research. If the government is serious about building ‘world class
universities’ the first thing it needs to do is to ensure that police states
do not get to ensure who does research and what research gets done. But
above all, as Michael Harner said in 1966, when the American Anthropological
Association was debating whether to pass a resolution against the war in
Vietnam, ‘genocide is not in the professional interests of anthropology.’