[Reader-list] Freeing Italian marine Salvatore Girone sends out the wrong message

[T Peter]

Freeing Italian marine Salvatore Girone sends out the wrong message

TK Devasia <http://www.firstpost.com/author/tkdevasia>  May 28, 2016 12:30
IST



http://www.firstpost.com/india/freeing-italian-marine-salvatore-girone-sends-out-the-wrong-message-2803608.html

The Supreme Court decision to release the lone Italian marine detained in
the country in connection with the killing of two Indian fishermen off the
coast of Kerala in 2012 has dashed the fishing community’s hopes for
justice.

National Fishworkers Forum (NWF) national secretary T Peter told
*Firstpost* that
the failure of the government counsel in opposing marine Salvatore Girone’s
plea for permission to return home had strengthened the suspicion that the
case is being driven by a deal between the governments in the two countries.

“If the allegation is true, it is the Narendra Modi
<http://www.firstpost.com/topic/person/narendra-modi-profile-20711.html>
government's
biggest betrayal of thousands of fishermen, who go to sea everyday to eke
out a life. While in the Opposition, the Bharatiya Janata Party had blamed
the UPA government of protecting the marines at the instance of Congress
chief Sonia Gandhi
<http://www.firstpost.com/topic/person/sonia-gandhi-profile-2030.html>,”
Peter said.

“If the marines were let off during the UPA regime, the BJP would have
created a huge furore citing Sonia’s Italian roots. It is an irony that
Modi is softer towards Italians than Sonia,” he added.
[image: File image of Salvatore Girone (centre) and his fellow accused
Latorre Massimiliano (right). Reuters]

File image of Salvatore Girone (centre) and his fellow accused Latorre
Massimiliano (right). Reuters

Peter said that the fishing community had expected that the Modi government
would give fisherfolk justice by ensuring maximum punishment to the killers
of the two fishermen as per Indian laws. The soft stance taken by the
counsel in the apex court shows that the government is not valuing the
lives of fishermen, he added.

“The government has let off the killers easily while hundreds of Indian
fishermen are languishing in jails in various countries for minor faults.
Modi, who has been globetrotting, has not made any moves to bring the
innocent fishermen back to the country,” Peter said.

The forum secretary said that the fishing community in the country would
react to this betrayal strongly. The forum has called a meeting of various
fishermen’s bodies in the state capital of Thiruvananthapuram on Friday to
discuss a joint action plan against the failure of the authorities in
protecting the lives of fishermen.

“Our concern is not about the present case, but the message it sends to the
world. If the two marines are not given the punishment they deserve, it
will send a message that anybody can kill Indian fishermen and escape. This
will deter the fishermen from going to the sea fearlessly,” he added.

Doramma, widow of Jelastine, who was one of the fishermen was killed by the
Italian marines during the course of fishing off the Alappuzha coast on 15
February, 2012, appears to have resigned herself to her fate. She said she
lost any hope of getting justice after the case was taken away from Kerala.

“We have lost our pillar of our life. We have left everything to God. Let
the Almighty decide what is right,” said Doramma, who has carefully
saved the entire sum of Rs one crore that she received as compensation from
the Italian government.

Doramma, who brings up her two sons with the salary she is getting from the
job offered by the Kerala government following the tragedy, goes to church
every day and prays for the soul of her husband.

Freddy John Bosco, owner of the fishing boat *St Antony*, on which the two
marines (aboard the *Enrica Lexie*) opened fire and killed the two Indian
fishermen, has also lost hope of getting any justice. The boat that was
taken into custody by the state police following the incident, is 'ruined
beyond repair'.

Freddy, who had moved the court to get back the boat, has abandoned the
vessel after waiting for more than three years. He has now joined another
fishing boat as a worker to bring up his family. He tries to manage his
life with whatever he gets as his wage.

“After employing fishermen for more than two decades, it was difficult for
me to work for another boat owner. There was no way. I had to take care of
my family. We have no other source of income. I am trying to come to terms
with the reality,” the former boat owner told *Firstpost*, adding, “I used
to earn an average of Rs three lakh a month from the boat. Some months, I
used to get up to Rs five lakh. It was a lucky boat. Even if I get the boat
back, it cannot be brought back to service. It is totally ruined."

Freddy, who was given compensation worth Rs 17 lakh by the Italian
government, was left with no money to buy another boat — something that
costs no less than Rs 45 lakh now. In any case, he had spent around Rs four
lakh on the lawyers who fought his case for compensation and reclaiming
possession of the boat.

 “The lawyers had promised they would help me get a new boat. I had
believed them, but now I have lost the hope. I am not expecting anything.
Let the marines live happily with their families. I will try to eke out a
living by working for other boats,” said Freddy.

Catholic priest Father Rajesh Martin, a distant relative of the late
Jelastine, is also of the same view. He has no complaints against anybody.
He considers the four years and more that the marines spent under detention
as adequate punishment for the wrong they did.

“After all, the two marines had no intention to kill innocent fishermen.
The death was the result of an accident. They have suffered enough
punishment for the mistake. Let them and the families of the fishermen
proceed with their normal lives now,” he said.

However, newly-sworn-in chief minister Pinarayi Vijayan is not ready to let
off the two marines. He has expressed strong displeasure over the manner in
which Modi government handled the case. He said that his government will
mount pressure on the Centre to bring the marines to book as per the Indian
laws. Pinarayi, who assumed office on Wednesday, said that the Left
Democratic Front has always been unhappy with the way the case was handled
by the Centre.

"We have made our position clear right from the time this incident
occurred; things never went the way it should have gone. The Centre never
pursued the case in the way it should have been taken up, and hence, this
has happened," said Pinarayi.