[Reader-list] The War Nobody Can Ever Win

[Aditya Raj Kaul]

The War Nobody Can Ever Win*BY **Rahul
Pandita<http://www.openthemagazine.com/category/author/rahul-pandita>

OPEN MAGAZINE

Link* -
http://www.openthemagazine.com/article/nation/the-war-nobody-can-ever-win

Two things arrived last month in Pavarvel village in the Naxal-affected area
of Gadchiroli, about 220 km from Nagpur. The first arrival was of a baby boy
born to an Adivasi woman, Indu Bai. He died within an hour of his birth. The
mother followed a day later. In Pavarvel and all other neighbouring
villages, pregnancies are handled by elderly women. For everything else,
there is Devi *puja*, since there is not even a primary health centre
around. There is no electricity, but the villagers claim that a Gram
Panchayat official comes every year to collect electricity tax. Water comes
from a ramshackle bore-pump.

The other arrival was that of a police party. It had not come to apprehend
Naxalites who villagers say turn up at any hour every now and then, demand
food, and slip back into the jungle. Pavarvel itself is in the thick of
forest. There is hardly any road, and if you don’t have a local guide, it
could take you weeks to figure out your location. In the forests, dense with
Mahua and other trees, there are memorials erected by Naxalites in memory of
their fallen comrades.

So, yes, the police arrived and went straight to Bajirao Potawe’s house and
beat him up. “With their boots and *lathis*,” he says. “They said bad things
to my mother and sister, called me a bastard, and said how dare my family
accuse them of rape,” he recounts. Then they made him run errands like
fetching water to cook a meal of *dal* and rice they had brought along.
Potawe himself hasn’t been able to eat such meals for a long time. In fact,
he has been living with his wife without a marriage ceremony; it would’ve
taken a feast for his fellow villagers, and for them to gift the couple some
rice. There simply wasn’t enough. Rice is a luxury for Potawe and his
neighbours.

The rape which the police party referred to happened with a 13-year-old
girl, the sister-in-law of Bajirao Potawe’s brother, Kaju Potawe. The girl,
from the neighbouring village of Tudmel, had come to his sister’s house for
treatment of an illness through Devi *puja*, and had stayed back, working as
a labourer at a school construction site nearby. It was on the evening of 4
March 2009 that a party of Maharashtra Police’s C-60 Commando group—a
special anti-Naxal force of policemen mostly from Adivasi regions—came to
Pavarvel, led by their notorious commander Munna Thakur. Reports suggest
that the group saw a man running with a tribal water-flask made of dried
pumpkin. The police fired at him, but he got away. It was the misfortune of
the Potawe family that the man ran off towards the forest behind their
house. Within minutes, the police party entered their house and clobbered
Kaju Potawe, who had just returned from the jungle with wild berries. “They
kept asking about Naxal whereabouts. When I said I didn’t know, they hit me
even more,” he says.

It was then that the police party saw Kaju’s sister-in-law, the 13-year-old.
“They dragged her by her hair and accused her of being a Naxal,” says Kaju.
Later, they asked another villager Dayaram Jangi and his family, and also a
school teacher they had put up, to vacate their house. The girl was forced
into the house and held captive along with a few men of the village who the
police suspected of being Naxals. The next morning, she was taken to a
nearby field. Blindfolded, with her hands tied, she was raped several times.

A fact-finding team that visited her after the incident was told by the girl
that the police did ‘*badmaash kaam*’ with her. She told them that the first
person who raped her was Munna Thakur. “He said I must have heard of his
name as he pushed himself on me,” the girl told the fact-finding team. The
girl added that she had fainted several times during her ordeal.

At about 10 am, a helicopter landed in Pavarvel to take the girl and other
suspects to Gadchiroli town. In a place where there’s not even a bullock
cart to take an ill person to hospital, the state machinery spared a
helicopter to ferry a 13-year-old girl accused of being a Naxal. Of course,
no charge was proven against her. As a damage-control exercise, Munna Thakur
was later transferred.

Just how does the State expect the people of Pavarvel to inform them of
Naxal whereabouts? That too, when this is not the only instance of police
atrocities in this village? In 2006, 17-year-old Ramsay Jangi was picked up
by C-60 commandos and beaten up severely. When his cousin Mathru Jangi went
pleading that he was innocent, the police assured him that he will be freed
after first-aid. That night, the villagers saw Munna Thakur. They heard him
shouting at his men, instructing them to ‘finish off’ the work. A moment
later, they heard gunshots, several of them. The police had shot Ramsay
Jangi dead. The body was taken to Dhanora taluka.

After ten days, the police came back and asked Ramsay’s father Manik Jhangi
to come and collect his son’s body. But nobody went, fearing arrest. The
police disposed of the body.

Manik Jhangi has kept the empty cartridges of the bullets that killed his
son. “My son’s body must have rotted,” he whispers.

“No, they inject something inside the body to keep it fresh,” interjects a
boy with some education. “But he is gone, gone forever,” Manik Jhangi sobs
silently, his tears mixing with sweat.

“We fear going into the jungle now because if the police finds us, they will
kill us,” says a man.

“Tell me, how are we supposed to survive?”

***

I arrive in Gadchiroli after spending two weeks in Andhra Pradesh, mostly in
the erstwhile Naxal bastion of North Telangana. This is the area that top
Naxal leaders like Ganapathi and Kishenji come from. It is from this region
that a number of bright young men and women—engineers, eye surgeons, PhD
students—turned revolutionaries. Almost 30 years before that helicopter
landed in Pavarvel, the first squad of Naxals came to Gadchiroli after
crossing the Godavari river from Andhra Pradesh’s Adilabad district. It was
led by a young Dalit boy Peddi Shankar, who worked in a coal mine before he
turned Naxal. Shortly afterwards, he was shot dead in an encounter with the
police on the banks of Pranhita, a sub-river of the Godavari. Within 2-3
years of his death, the Naxal movement spread like wildfire in this region.
Naxals first targeted contractors involved in the *tendu* leaf (used in *
beedi* making) and bamboo trade. These contractors would fleece poor
Adivasis and pay them a pittance for a hard day’s labour. After the Naxal
intervention, these contractors were forced to pay better. Naxals also went
after government representatives like forest and police officials who would
often harass and exploit Adivasis. The police tried to wrest control from
Naxal hands, but it was too late. Gadchiroli was soon made part of
Dandakaranya, the Naxal guerilla base. The police just couldn’t act against
them, and it ended up alienating the local populace further through a
sustained programme of repression. The scenario now is more or less the
same. Unable to act against Naxals, the police end up killing boys like
Ramsay Jangi. And infuriating villagers in places like Pavarvel.

***

A day after the Dantewada attack, Gadchiroli is tense. In Armori, a town on
the Nagpur-Gadchiroli road, I wait at a local activist’s house over a
breakfast of puffed rice, jalebi and tea, while he tries to find me a
resource person in an east Gadchiroli area. It is after several attempts
that the activist gets through on the phone. The conversation lasts 2-3
minutes. “He is worried and says you shouldn’t come here,” the activist
says. “Actually, the police is on the prowl. Anyone who goes into a village
gets noticed, and after you are gone, they will harrass my friend,” he
clarifies. But elsewhere, I need to take chances, he tells me. I take my
chances, and that is how I get to Pavarvel. And in touch with a CRPF patrol
party.

***

The trees are bare, and the young soldiers of the CRPF long for some shade.
In about eight weeks, the trees will be full of foliage. But before it can
bring some comfort, it could take these men closer to death. From behind the
thick foliage, Naxal guerillas could zero in unnoticed and do a Dantewada on
them. The CRPF party has arrived in a deep forest zone of Maharashtra’s
Gadchiroli region at about 5 am in the morning, carrying packed lunch and
water filled in empty Fanta bottles. The water lasts only a few hours. There
is nothing to do, except wait under the oppressive sun and ward off flies
adamant on clinging to your skin. The eyelids droop in fatigue, but here
that could mean death. It has just been a day since 76 of their colleagues
died in Dantewada. “We are all scared,” says one, “Some want a change of
job.”

The morale of these men in uniform couldn’t be lower. Ever since the
Dantewada incident, the phones haven’t stopped ringing. Anxious family
members and relatives are calling every hour to check whether they are safe.
The people who died in Dantewada were colleagues, batchmates, and in
conflict zones like Kashmir, some of them even became soul mates. “I lost
one of my batchmates in Dantewada,” says their officer, wiping sweat from
his brow and from the ammunition magazine of his AK-47 assault rifle. “We
are fighting a lost battle. We don’t know who our enemy is. Adivasis share
nothing with us.”

The officer talks about visiting several villages, tracking Naxals. He says
most of them don’t understand a word of the language spoken by Adivasis.
Those who do, get no clue from villagers. “We have even tried asking young
children, but not a word comes out of their mouth. We have no intelligence
at all,” he says.

The group has walked in the morning as part of a road-opening party to
ensure that this stretch is safe for their vehicles and men to move on.
“Move on where?” he asks. “We are all waiting for evening so that we could
retire to the camp,” the officer says. He takes a big gulp from his water
bottle and it is over. “You think we are fighting for India?” he asks, and
then replies himself. “*Jhaat ka baal...!*” he lets out a familiar
expletive, “We are fighting to save our lives. Do you think this
bullet-proof jacket will save us if a 70-kg explosive explodes beneath our
feet?”

As an officer, back in camp, he may get a fan, but none of his men would
have that luxury. They will sleep in tents with no fans, braving vicious
swarms of mosquitoes.

“*Saala, yahan ka macchar bhi *Naxali *hai*,” quips a soldier. All of them
laugh.

There is the sound of a motorcycle on the nearby road. The laughter
vanishes. Fingers go back to the trigger. The other hand feels for the
walkie-talkie. Day or night doesn’t matter around here—there is no rest.

The officer says he was on deputation with a special force in Delhi. “Every
morning I would run 20 miles to keep myself fit so that I am not asked to
leave the force and hence Delhi. But now I am here in these treacherous
forests, counting every day the way prisoners do in jail,” he says.

It is still many hours before the party can hope to retire for the night.

“When you write this report, please write that wars are not fought from
tents,” says the officer, shaking his sweaty hand to emphasise the point.“We
don’t want our bodies to be injected with formalin, as they did with those
who died in Dantewada, and then sent back home,” he says as I get back into
the car.

I roll down my car windows.

The car engine grunts, but the officer’s voice reaches me above the noise.
“Everything ends with formalin,” he says.