[Reader-list] Two Sad Incidents

[S. Jabbar]

Statement on Maoist attack on police camp in West Bengal

We the undersigned would like to express our deep concern at the
ongoing conflict in the Jangalmahal area of West Bengal where forces
of the CPI (Maoist) and the Indian government have been confronting
each other for the past year.

The regular incidents of violence have resulted in the tragic loss of
too many lives already- both of combatants and innocent civilians-
and needs to come to an immediate end. The systematic annihilation of
opponents and the gross violations of human rights by both sides in
the conflict are a serious setback to the task of building a more just
and humane Indian society.

In this context the  attack by the CPI (Maoist) cadre on the Silda
police camp in West Bengal on 15 February killing 24 policemen
represents a severe escalation of an already ugly  situation in the
Jangalmahal area. Coming at a time when there are active attempts
being made by many sections of civil society to get the Indian
government to call off its proposed ŒOperation Green Hunt¹ against the
Maoists this provocative act by the latter can only result in a
hardening of attitudes all around.

While there are many genuine grievances of the local population
against the West Bengal state government and the security forces
operating in the tribal areas of West Midnapore ­ including arbitrary
arrests and killings- none of them can be used to justify the latest
Maoist action. In fact the purely military methods adopted by the CPI
(Maoist) are inimical to the task of finding both short and long-term
political solutions to the long-standing problems of the local people.

Use of violence for political goals, however lofty, cannot mean
violation of fundamental principles of humanity and there are also
basic norms and conventions that need to be adhered to.  Every such
killing and violation adds to the spiral of grief, trauma and revenge
that is already consuming our polity; and from which the common people
desperately need relief.

Monday¹s attack on the Silda police camp also represents a
contradiction of the CPI (Maoist)¹s own stated position, through media
interviews of its top most leaders, of the need for talks with the
government of India and the prevention of an Œall out war¹.  The
massacre of police personnel also shows a lack of seriousness on the
part of the CPI (Maoist) about its own publicly stated demand that for
Œany kind of democratic work, the ban on the Party and Mass
Organizations have to be lifted¹.

The Indian State too should immediately stop all its violations of
human rights in the Jangalmahal area, sincerely settle the problems of
the local people and not use the latest Maoist attack as an excuse to
go ahead with further intensification of the conflict.
We the undersigned sincerely hope for a quick and peaceful resolution
to the conflict, which is putting at grave risk the lives of a very
large number of innocent people trapped between the Maoists and the
Indian State.

Prof. A. Marx, Chennai
Bhaskar Vishwanathan, Chennai
Praful Bidwai, New Delhi
Dilip Simeon, New Delhi
Apoorvanand, New Delhi
Aditya Nigam,  New Delhi
Nivedita Menon, New Delhi
Amit Sengupta, New Delhi
Satya Sivaraman, New Delhi

and others..





> From: Prakash K Ray <pkray11 at gmail.com>
> Date: Tue, 23 Feb 2010 14:59:03 +0530
> To: <reader-list at sarai.net>
> Subject: Re: [Reader-list] Two Sad Incidents
> 
> Hi,

It is horrible to live in these violent times where the level of
> violence
has surpassed all its earlier references. I share Shuddha's views
> expressed
in his post. Few days back, a 200-strong Maoist terror gang raided a
> tribal
village in Jamui district of Bihar. The gang killed and burnt to death
> 12
villagers including a woman and a child. The terrorists have kidnapped
> more
than 10 villagers whoes fate is still unknown. Before leaving the
> village,
the Maoists torched the entire village. The false claim of the Maoist
> terror
that they fight for the poor and the tribal once again stands
> exposed.
Another shocking part of this ghastly act is the use of child
> guerrilas as
young as 12-13 years by the Maoist death squad.

However, I am
> not at all shocked on the silence of numerous 'activists' who
are 'champions'
> of peace, dignity and human
> rights.

Regards,
PKR
_________________________________________
reader-list:
> an open discussion list on media and the city.
Critiques & Collaborations
To
> subscribe: send an email to reader-list-request at sarai.net with subscribe in
> the subject header.
To unsubscribe:
> https://mail.sarai.net/mailman/listinfo/reader-list 
List archive:
> &lt;https://mail.sarai.net/pipermail/reader-list/>